Author: Josin L. McQuein
Series: Arclight, #1
Release date: April 23rd 2013
Publisher: Greenwillow Books
Hardcover, 400 pages
Source: Publisher for review
Buy: The Book Depository
No one crosses the wall of light . . . except for one girl who doesn’t remember who she is, where she came from, or how she survived. A harrowing, powerful debut thriller about finding yourself and protecting your future—no matter how short and uncertain it may be.The Arclight is the last defense. The Fade can’t get in. Outside the Arclight’s border of high-powered beams is the Dark. And between the Light and the Dark is the Grey, a narrow, barren no-man’s-land. That’s where the rescue team finds Marina, a lone teenage girl with no memory of the horrors she faced or the family she lost. Marina is the only person who has ever survived an encounter with the Fade. She’s the first hope humanity has had in generations, but she could also be the catalyst for their final destruction. Because the Fade will stop at nothing to get her back. Marina knows it. Tobin, who’s determined to take his revenge on the Fade, knows it. Anne-Marie, who just wishes it were all over, knows it.When one of the Fade infiltrates the Arclight and Marina recognizes it, she will begin to unlock secrets she didn’t even know she had. Who will Marina become? Who can she never be again?
As someone who’s grown tired of the dystopian genre altogether, I’ve become exceedingly difficult to please. So rarely do these stories work for me anymore, it takes a lot to keep me interested, but Josin McQuein succeeded with seeming ease.
By far the best thing about Arclight is its pacing. The plot moves forward unrelentingly, mercilessly, giving the reader no time to breathe. The story is full of excitement, with strong elements of horror to ensure the reader’s interest throughout. The sweet and unusual romance serves to soften the rough edges, but it never becomes dominant and overwhelming, which I appreciated greatly.
Unfortunately, the rapid pacing leaves very little time for the reader to bond with the characters. While I liked Marina and appreciated the fact that she was no delicate flower, a lack of emotional connection was notable. It was, in part, due to her personality: she was meant to be a bit detached and strange. Her connection with Tobin, odd as it was, made me understand her better and appreciate her more.
But emotion-wise, the real protagonist of this book is Tobin himself. Out of all the characters, he is the one with enough emotional complexity to keep me glued to the pages. He often did things without really knowing why he was doing them, which was understandable given his age the circumstances, and it was always interesting to try to figure out his motives.
Among several weaknesses of Arclight, the writing is its Achilles’ heel. Not badly written per se, but poorly structured, the story tended to get extremely confusing, especially in more eventful chapters. Given the rapid pacing, those chapters made the majority of the book. Marina’s communication with the Fade was also messy, partly because it was meant to be, and partly because of the way it was written.
Another thing that deems mentioning is predictability. The twists and turns that were meant to surprise or even shock were painfully evident from the first few chapters, minus the few finer details of the story. It is a shame in what is otherwise a great story, but it’s also something I can live with, if the good outweighs the bad, which it certainly does.
The gorgeous cover, in this case, actually hides a very good story, which is a rarity indeed. If you haven’t yet decided to read Arclight, I hope this review will push you in the right direction. Arclight wraps up nicely, but the world McQuein created is filled with possibilities, which gives me so much hope for Meridian, the sequel scheduled for an April 2014 release.
A copy of this book was kindly provided by the publisher for review purposes. No considerations, monetary or otherwise, have influenced the opinions expressed in this review.
I was definitely not a fan of this book. The pacing was good, but the characters did not stick to me at all. :(
ReplyDeleteLovely review, Maja! <33
I had heard very good things about this book from Kristen so I added it to my TBR list but your review has made me decide I need to push it up to the front soon!
ReplyDeleteGreat review, Maja!
Gosh, another predictable twist. But less than memorable characters is grounds for reading postponement, for sure.
ReplyDeleteGreat review, Maja.
As much as I did enjoy this story, I definitely agree about not getting to know the characters very well. With all that was going on, I didn't get a good hold on Marina.
ReplyDeleteGlad this kept your interest but disappointed you never had that bonding with the characters that can be so crucial.
ReplyDeleteI am starting to wonder sometimes if it isn't going to be a normal thing getting burnt out on genres and needing something spectacular to pull you out of that funk? I am starting to notice I am having that problem as well with some genres.
I enjoyed ARCLIGHT but I think I had the same reaction about the characters. I may or may not read the next book, although the cover sure is drawing me in, these covers are so well done!
ReplyDeleteMy mom is actually reading and reviewing this one for the blog and she was really pleased with it overall as well Maja! I don't usually mind predictability in my books, especially if, as you mentioned, the good parts of the story outweigh my small niggles. It's too bad on the confusion at the end though, but hopefully some of that will be cleared up in book two and you'll see an improvement in the structure. Gorgeous review!
ReplyDeleteI really do not know about this one..hm
ReplyDeleteit's nice, I didn't know this one. You're right about dystopia, at the end it's easy to be tired of it. I'm reading a great dystopian series I confess by Traci L slatton too.
ReplyDeleteI wasn't a fan of this and have up early on because of, as you mentioned, the writing. I couldn't push forth, but I'm glad you found something to enjoy in this novel, Maja.
ReplyDeleteHmm..there's quite a lot of red flags that would deter me for enjoying this book as I too am getting so tired of the dystopians lately. Not sure if this one is for me though. Glad the book was able to capture your attention, Maja.
ReplyDeleteI haven't read this, but the premise sounds interesting enough. I honestly haven't read much dystopia so it's nice to get other people's thoughts. That's great the pacing was good.
ReplyDeleteI haven't read a lot of stellar reviews for this one. I amm not convinced this one is for mee.
ReplyDeleteSounds like a mixed bag. Maybe if I come across it at some point I'll give it a try.
ReplyDeleteOkay, I do need to read it. All the bad points you mentioned could really ruin a book and yet you enjoyed this one. I am so curious now! I'm a bit leery mostly of the confusion, but in my state... it would be natural. ;) I might have to library book it to see.
ReplyDeleteI think I pretty much agree. I know I gave this one three stars, but I don't remember what my complaints are. I know I did remark on how the imagery didn't always work for me as I am such a visual reader. It was hard for me to picture some of these settings and scenes as they were written. But I still really liked it and thought it was fairly original, considering how BLOATED this genre it.
ReplyDeleteI downloaded this one but never really felt much of an urge to pick it up in the end. I'll probably wait until the new year now so that the wait for the sequel isn't too long. Great review as always, Maja! It's a shame that there wasn't much emotional connection with Marina *which worries me a little) but I'm glad that Tobin managed to be a highlight.
ReplyDeleteI don't know, you make the story sound interesting and the last paragraph makes me want to pick it up, but bad writing is always a deterrent. Maybe it is on a really good sale in some shady bookstore or obscure website.
ReplyDeleteI don't mind some predictability if the story has some fantastic world-building or great characters. This one sounds like a mix, but the ending you talked about gives me hope that it's only going to get better. Definitely keeping this one on my list for the future. Thanks Maja :)
ReplyDeleteI love fast paced books but I can see what you mean about it taking away from connecting more emotionally with the characters. It looks like my type of read. I hope I'll get to it :)
ReplyDeleteI didn't have success with McQuien's Premeditated. Her writing style wasn't for me, so I'm not sure if this would work either. Hmm...Wonderful review, Maja. I think I'll wait for the response to the sequel before deciding. :)
ReplyDeleteI've had this book for ages but never felt an urge to read it. I did meet her last month and it got me a little curious because she's got a little different of a personality. I'm trying to figure out how to word it without sounding rude, but I think she described it like she can't interpret other peoples emotions. Like she's slightly autistic. I think that's what she said. Geez, I hope I don't sound mean, I don't mean that at all. She was really nice, but it was clear that she 'read' things differently, that she interpreted things in another way. She did surprisingly well on a panel with several authors but said straight up that it was her biggest fear, talking to a group of people.
ReplyDeleteAnyway, that experience has me curious about how she builds her characters. I guess I'll have to read this one of these days.
I started this one earlier in the year and got bored with it, and only recently picked it up and finished it a couple weeks ago. I had many of the same issues you did (particularly the predictability and confusion over some of the climactic scenes between Marina and the Fade), but overall I am glad I finished the book. It has such a unique premise, one I haven't really seen in YA fiction, and I quite liked that it felt more sci-fi/horror than straight up dystopian.
ReplyDeletePoorly structured writing style? I guess its something I'll have to experience to really get what you're saying.
ReplyDelete